Fascinating New Find About Richard Mellen

Just found a newish website whose author is apparently unwilling to commit to scholarly diligence and credibility. Doug Sinclair wrote a paper about Richard Mellen of Massachusetts, alleged father of Simon Mellen of Sherborne and Framingham.

Mr. Sinclair states that his website doesn’t claim to the standard of scholarly journals, and it certainly doesn’t.

Further, he ignores the clear, cogent, and concise statements at the beginning of my paper on Richard Mellen, and the genealogy of Simon Mellen, that they are each “extended literature review[s].” Further, the next paragraph in those publications cogently states that the focus of each was on “published record sets.” What is not credible or clear about that?

Mr. Sinclair fails to cite his sources for the statements concerning my work, yet appears to cite everything else he writes about. Nothing new was presented that hadn’t been already written about by myself or others, just pictures. One picture in particular clearly shows he read my blog article and paper about Richard “Maling” aka “Waling.” The picture he posted clearly shows a “W”.

Any diligent genealogical researcher will use both of our works as clues only. Any diligent genealogical researcher will also follow the BCG Code of Ethics in using our works.

NPM

Sarah Agnes and Nettie Christina Mellen, Sisters Born too Close to Each Other

According to my volume of Descendants of Simon Mellen, c. 1636-1694, pages 195-196, two sisters were born within 8 months of each other. Sarah Agnes Mellen was born 13 November 1869 and Nettie Christina Mellen was born 15 July 1870.

There is an incorrect date for one of the two.

The source I gave, Cutter’s Genealogical and Personal Memoirs Relating to the Families of the State of Massachusetts, volume 4, page 2171, shows the dates given above.

Checking the Massachusetts vital records on the NEHGS website, americanancestors.org, for Cambridge, I find that an unnamed female surnamed Mellen was born on 20 November 1869. This is likely to be Sarah Agnes Mellen.

Nettie Christina Mellen, on the other hand, according to the NEHGS records, was born in July 1871, and died 14 July 1872, aged one year. There was no day given in the date field of the birth record.